For everything, there is a season... even in fundraising

Dear Fr. Zagloba,

So I came out to my truck this morning and found that I had a flat tire.


What does this have to do with fundraising? I’ll tell you.

The other day, I read a great article by a Catholic priest on the topic of fundraising. He explained how he increased his offertory by 30% without even asking.

It was the same feeling I had when I found my truck with a flat tire: dumbstruck. Here I am, telling you that fundraising REQUIRES asking, and here he is describing how he succeeded without doing so. I looked at the article with the same expression as I looked at my flat tire.

So what is going on here? I had been thinking about this article for a couple of days, trying to understand how Fr. Alan’s success fits in with my knowledge of fundraising. Then it hit me: he was closing the loop on his parish appeal.

Catholics are not ATMs in a parish appeal

So far, I’ve mostly written about the ‘asking’ part of fundraising. I focus on this because it’s the hardest part to do correct and the easiest part to do wrong, but asking is just the beginning. Great fundraising focuses on fostering relationships with your donors.

Meaning, you don’t treat your patrons like an ATM (Automatic Teller Machine) that you can withdraw money from at any time. Rather, you have to consider ‘closing the loop’, which means to recognise that there is a life-cycle to every donation, especially when you are running a parish appeal. This life cycle is:

1. First, you ASK

2. Then, you RECEIVE

3. Then, you THANK

(Gratitude is something that is vital yet often missed in church fundraising. This doesn’t simply mean once, for example after someone gives. Gratitude, when done correctly, is done frequently.)

4. Then, you DO

What you said you were going to do, you go out and accomplish it. You also communicate to everyone, not just donors, what you are achieving.

5. Then, you CELEBRATE the parish appeal

It’s always important to communicate what you have accomplished with your donors. Take the necessary time to stop and enjoy the fruits of everyone’s labor.

6. Last, REPEAT the cycle

I think a lot of donors feel perpetually inside the first part of the lifecycle, always being asked for money. Their donations then get sucked into a black hole, never to be seen again, as they are never thanked properly. Instead, it’s back to being asked again.

Also, when starting a fundraising campaign or appeal, you don’t have to start with the ask. Like Fr Alan, he began with step number four, ‘doing’. This provided momentum to accomplish the other steps.

A proper thank you goes a long way in a parish appeal

Even after being thanked, donors want to know how their donation did something productive. It’s important to recognize that behind each donation is a person, a story and hard work. It’s never just a monetary transaction. When you complete the lifecycle by communicating and celebrating the outcomes and successes, people get excited about giving again because they know that their gift has made an impact. They also learn that another one will do the same.

Fr. Alan realised this. He decided not to ask for more money because it was not the right time in his parish to do so. This wasn’t where everyone was in the life cycle. Instead, he worked to tighten the belt financially, did some inexpensive but greatly needed physical upkeep and communicated to his parishioners what he was trying to do and where they were succeeding.

By focusing on the DOING of being a good steward, he was enabling his parish to CELEBRATE how the church that was more attractive, better managed, and better maintained. The visual cue of newly painted walls helped the parishioners see how their gifts made an impact. As a result, they were willing to increase their gifts because they wanted to see more.

There is an ASK in the bASKet!

I do have to disagree slightly with Father on one minor point. It’s not true that he didn’t ask. During every Mass, there is an ask, even if nobody likes to talk about it. After the homily, when the ushers pass the baskets through the pews, that is an ask. It is a gentle one, but I know from my personal experience that I feel it, especially if there is nothing in my wallet.

By sharing the results of good stewardship, Fr. Alan improved the success of the bASKet: a 30% increase is extraordinary. He also runs a better parish appeal. I celebrate his tremendous accomplishment and rejoice that his parish responded so well to his loving attention. When he completed the life cycle and allowed parishioners to celebrate successful stewardship, the fundraising cycle started afresh and brought in more money.

So, I think I have plucked this particular thorn out my understanding of fundraising and a parish appeal. Now, I have to get the nail out of my tire.


Nathan - The Almoner

-> Next letter - Tax Collecting vs. Evangelizing

Need some new ideas on how to fundraise? Check out The Fundraiser’s Playbook and find the fundraising strategy that will work best for you!